How do men and women tackle imposter syndrome differently?

Imposter syndrome, self-saboteur

Have you ever felt like you were a fraud in your job? Like you aren’t qualified or good enough to be where you are? Waiting to be found out?

Chances are you are suffering from a very common issue called ‘imposter syndrome’. Imposter syndrome spans across all genders and work places. But how imposter syndrome manifests itself between men and women can be very different. From who admits to feeling imposter syndrome to who asks for help; there are some interesting differences between men and women when it comes to suffering with self-doubt.

Firstly, what is imposter syndrome?

Imposter syndrome can range from annoying, niggling, self-deprecating thoughts – all the way through to a deeply ingrained mindset that prevents us from progressing and developing in our careers. Because of the nature of imposter syndrome, people often don’t realise they are even suffering from it. It can be often be an invisible, built in part of our mindset and it is incredibly self-limiting.

The biggest impact of imposter syndrome is your mind stopping you doing things. For instance, you might believe there’s no point in putting yourself up for that award or for going for that job interview because the imposter syndrome part of your brain is saying “there’s no point in doing it – you won’t get it anyway”. In this way, it’s prevalent in your brain even before it’s become a conscious thought. You’ve already rejected those opportunities because deep down imposter syndrome is making you think you’re not good enough. Yet you don’t even realise it is imposter syndrome stopping you. It’s a vicious circle in the truest sense of the term.

How men and women differ when it comes to confidence

We know that imposter syndrome affects both men and women equally. New research released by My Confidence Matters has found that three quarters of people admit to regularly lacking confidence in themselves when it comes to their careers. This lack of confidence is seen across the board – regardless of gender or business sector. However, there is a notable disparity between the extent of men and women’s confidence levels. More women than men experience a lack of confidence in the workplace (79 per cent of women vs 62 per cent of men). On top of this, 47 per cent of those women who admitted they were lacking confidence, feared that they aren’t getting enough support from their manager to overcome this and dispel their feelings of imposter syndrome.

What I have seen in my work with businesses, particularly when working alongside people in managerial roles is that women tend to admit to imposter syndrome far more than men do. Though I would hasten a bet that men do indeed feel it a lot more than they let on. This is because men tend to believe it makes them seem vulnerable – an emotion they dislike as they, wrongly, see it as appearing cowardly – even though we know this is far from true. Certainly, I have witnessed that women tend to doubt their ability more, whilst men tend to overestimate their abilities. Culturally that’s how ‘career men’ have always done it. These are stereotypes that still play a big part in our modern world of work. Some men think to climb the ranks they have to be loud and show off their successes. Imposter syndrome doesn’t fit in anywhere into their success plan, so it is never something that has been planned for or expected. This can make men feel the symptoms of imposter syndrome even more, however they are still unlikely to admit it and seek help.  Whereas women often shy away from celebrating their successes, in general they are humbler. There is evidence to suggest that women are just penalized rather than rewarded when they display the same self-assured behaviour as men. Women however, are not as likely to attach the stigma of weakness onto their feelings of imposter syndrome, therefore are more likely to open up to colleagues. Overall, women tend to self-report more imposter syndrome than men. But researchershave investigated and found that men experienced more stress when getting negative feedback and with the prospect of that feedback being shared with their superiors’. But times are changing. Our workplaces are shifting, and gender stereotypes are, fortunately, being ebbed away.

So, male or female, what on earth can we do about it?

I have complied a list of my five top tips to help when imposter syndrome strikes.

  1. Recognise that imposter syndrome is just a feeling. You are being hijacked by a belief that is unfounded. When those negative thoughts come up hold them to account. Question them.
  2. Admit it to yourself. Don’t keep pushing those feelings and thoughts down deeper- they’ll only grow and become more difficult to overcome.
  3. Talk about it. Getting practical and pragmatic feedback from other people can be really reassuring. Ask the people you work with, clients and colleagues what they think your key strengths are. When praise comes from other people our brain is more likely to believe it. Go back over this feedback regularly to help build up your self-esteem.
  4. Remind yourself of your capabilities. The likelihood is that you have done something like this work, or challenge that has triggered imposter syndrome before. You have been successful is the past, you will be successful in the future.
  5. Feel the fear and do it anyway. Have the courage to leap because you’ve done the hard work all throughout your career to date. The chances are, you’re going to be fine. Once you know you it’s just imposter syndrome, you can actively ignore it, or do the opposite of what it is suggesting.

Kate Turner, Motivational LeadershipAbout the author

Kate Turner is the founder and director of Motivational Leadership. She is an experienced leadership development coach and trainer who has designed and delivered programmes to senior executives across a range of sectors.

Kate has a natural, results-focused approach. Her command of a range of management and leadership tools enables her to offer her clients helpful frameworks which act as a back-drop to development discussions.

Kate works alongside leaders who are passionate about creating sustainable change in their organisations. She helps shape and strengthen organisational culture and aligning key behaviours to core values. To achieve this, her emphasis is on building employee engagement and generating commitment across everyone in the organisation. In her work with clients, Kate demonstrates and delivers culture change to drive the business forward, fostering employee engagement and inciting passion across all levels, so that everyone feels committed to the same outcomes.

Upcoming Events

Job Board Banner

Related Posts